Available IPI Books

Friday, February 18, 2011

2011 Indians Top 50 Prospects: #28 Tyler Holt

Tyler Holt – Outfielder
Born: 03/10/1989 – Height: 6’0” – Weight: 190 – Bats: Right – Throws: Right

(Photo: Tony Lastoria)
History: The Indians selected Holt in the 10th round of the 2010 Draft out of Florida State University. He was signed a few days before the August 16th signing deadline for a well overslot $500,000 signing bonus. He played for Team USA in 2009 hitting .371 with 28 runs scored, 24 walks and 19 stolen bases.

Strengths: Holt is a very talented player with good all around skills and is a very interesting leadoff hitting prospect. He was arguably the best table-setter in college baseball the past few years with his very good speed and very advanced approach at the plate. He only has below average power, but he sprays line drives all over the field from pole to pole and makes consistent, hard contact. He is a smart baserunner with plus speed, and is a very sound defender showing very good range in center field with an average arm.

Holt shows an intensity on the field and at the plate that is beyond almost anything the Indians have had in awhile. He is a fiery player who lets his emotions show on the field, and his intensity and heart are two intangibles that few players match. He has an excellent makeup and work ethic, and his instincts as a hitter, runner, and defender are off the charts which help him play above his tools. He has the potential to be a Brett Gardner type of player by using a combination of his approach, speed, intelligence, and heart to make him a potential starter and complementary player in the big leagues.

Opportunities: While Holt’s aggressive approach is part of his game, it is also something that can at times detract from it. During his time in the minors he will need to learn how to tone it down a little so he can make it through the emotional grind of a full season. The Indians by no means want him to stop playing with such a high intensity as they understand it is part of who he is and what helps him overachieve; however, they just want him to learn how to better manage and control it. One area of focus at the plate will be getting his hands in a better load position as his current setup with the open crouch is not ideal.  Due to his average at best throwing arm, it may eventually push him out of center field to left field or as a fourth outfielder, which lessens his value.

Outlook: The fact Holt made his debut in Low-A Lake County and not at short-season Single-A Mahoning Valley shows how much further along the Indians think he is than most players coming out of the draft last year. He doesn't project as a big league star, but depending on who you talk to the general consensus is he will play in the big leagues some day in some kind of role, be it as a fourth outfielder or a regular. He should open the 2011 season at High-A Kinston.

YearAgeTeamLvlGABRH2B3BHRRBIBBSOSBAVGOBPSLGOPS
200819Florida StC682508381102341644615.324.471.416.887
200920Florida StC632378795232528544734.401.517.5781.095
201021Florida StC6825992922631348594830.355.480.6291.109
201021Lake CountyA22701220820815125.286.409.457.866
MiLB Totals22701220820815125.286.409.457.866

3 comments:

Much like in many pitching categories, we have an abundance of similar skill sets that Tyler Holt brings to the table. Many in close proximity within the system. Could be seeing some bottlenecks developing that could seriously hinder the advancement/development of some worthy prospects in the near future. It will interesting to see how Tony ranks them all..I'm sure they'll be appearing soon on this list.

I tend to agree with Dan. I think the Tribe should try and diversify their player selection. They seem to get in a funk and draft a certain skill set over and aver...

Years before it was soft tossing lefties, before that it was big, slow, slugging first baseman. Now the flavor of the week is power relief pitchers. So tired of every pitcher they seem to take in the draft, they are then converted to the BP. It would be nice if the system could start producing some above average starters.

Out of victor, CC, and Lee we get one god damn starting pitcher. Unreal. Pitching is the name of the game. If you are trading away your Cy Young winners, you might want to think about trying to replace them with some starting pitching.

I have serious reservations about how this FO handles their players and development. Added to that their obsession with over the hill re-tread players and platoons, it makes me want to jump out a window.

I have to disagree with Brent. The Indians do seem to be stocking up on power pitchers who could either make it to the rotation or bullpen but I am not sure that is a bad thing. I think the influx of Tyler Holt type players has something to do with the impending FA of Sizemore and even Choo.

Martinez, Lee and Victor got us at least three possible starters in Masterson, Carrasco and Knapp. Not to mention Laporta, Brantley, Bryson, Price, Hagadon, Donald, and Marson. Plus, we got Scott Barnes for Garko, Santana for Blake and Corey Kubler for Westbrook.


My dream is the rotation starts to take this shape:

Carmona

Carrasco

White

Masterson

De La Cruz/Garland/Pomeranz


The bullpen is a very bad place for teams such as the Tribe to invest in the FA market which is why I think you see the team stock piling these guys. Plus, anyone who has watched the team over the past 5 or so years understand the importance of a rock solid bullpen. Which is why having Perez, Sipp, Hagadon, Bryson, Putnam, Judy, Tomlin, Kluber, Price, Stowell, Lee and maybe even Rondon or gasp Atom Miller bodes well for the future. Am I the only one who dreams of Miller getting healthy at last and joining a history making pen? I wouldn't be surprised if I was.


Thanks Tony for all of the great work and dedication, look forward to this everyday.

Post a Comment